40m QIL Cryo_Lab CTN SUS_Lab TCS_Lab OMC_Lab CRIME_Lab FEA ENG_Labs OptContFac Mariner WBEEShop
  PSL  Not logged in ELOG logo
Message ID: 2261     Entry time: Tue Dec 4 15:05:56 2018
Author: anchal 
Type: DailyProgress 
Category: TempCtrl 
Subject: Optimal circuit for transimpedance of temperature sensor for Vacuum Can 

Choosing better TIA opamp (Continued from ATF:2250):

I'm summarizing the analysis of Awade and Zach (40m:8125 and ATF:1752) in the context of the specific application of transimpedance amplifier for the AD590 temperature sensor.

Summary of offsets and thermal coefficients op amps
Parameter \\\\   opamp Unit OP27 OP07 LT1012 OPA827 OPA140 LT1028/LT1128
Input Voltage Offset \mu V 30 30 30 75 30 30
Thermal coefficient of input voltage offset \mu V/ K 0.2 0.3 0.2 0.1 0.35 0.25
Input current offset nA 15 0.9 0.03 0.003 0.005 25
Thermal coefficient of input current offset pA/K 80 8 0.3 Not mentioned Not mentioned Not mentioned
Long term offset drift \mu V/ Month 0.2 0.3 0.3 Not mentioned Not mentioned 0.3
Input bias current nA 20 1.5 0.08 0.003 0.005 40
Thermal coefficient of input bias current pA/K 100 13 0.6 Not mentioned Not mentioned Not mentioned
Voltage noise density nV/\sqrt{Hz} 3.5 @ 10Hz 10.3 @ 10Hz 17 @ 10Hz 7.5 @ 10Hz 8 @ 10 Hz 1 @ 10 Hz
Current noise density pA/\sqrt{Hz} 1.7 @ 10Hz 0.32 @ 10Hz 0.02 @ 10Hz 0.0022  @ 1kHz 0.0008 @ 1kHz 4.7 @ 10 Hz

AD590 datasheet says that it has input current noise density of 40 pA/\sqrt{Hz} without mentioning the frequency of this value or corner frequency (or any plot showing this data).

I did a liso analysis with a simple transimpedance circuit of transimpedance = 16667 Ohm and tried all the above opamps. Attached is input referred noise calculated by total output voltage noise density divided by the transfer function of the circuit.

It is clear from this analysis that we would be comfortable below 40 pA/\sqrt{Hz} with OP07, LT1012, OPA827, and OPA140. So to choose a particular opamp, we need to look into offset voltage and current drift of these opamps. The voltage offset drifts do not matter much as 1 uV/K translates to 60 uK/K of temperature readout difference per kelvin change in chip temperature. We need to achieve stability up to mK only. The current offset drift of 1pA/K translates as 1uK/K of temperature readout difference per kelvin change in chip temperature. So with given values, in my opinion, even current offset drift does not matter much. But it would be good to have low current offset and bias current features of FET inputs. So the winner is chosen as OPA827.

I'm attaching .fil and notebook file of the analysis in .zip file as well.

Edit: Wed Dec 5 15:39:29 2018

Adding one more calculation here. Assuming that the resistor used is thin film resistor with 50 ppm/K thermal drift, drift in transimpedance would be (1.6k*50e-6) Ohm/K. Then 1 K change in resistor temperature will look like:
\frac{300 \mu A \times (1.6e3 \times 50e-6 )\Omega}{1 \frac{\mu A}{K} \times 1.6e3 \Omega} = 15 mK 

15 mK change in perceived temperature. So this is the most important factor for us and we need to use the least possible thermal coefficient resistor available with very good insulation of the circuit. On Digikey, I'm seeing a minimum of 10ppm/K resistor for 1.65kOhm value. This should give us 3mK change per K change in resistor temperature. I'll look further if we can get even better resistors.

Attachment 1: VacCanTemSensorTIAOpampOptimization.pdf  21 kB  Uploaded Tue Dec 4 18:28:56 2018  | Hide | Hide all
Attachment 2: AD590TIAmp.zip  87 kB  Uploaded Tue Dec 4 18:41:47 2018
ELOG V3.1.3-