40m QIL Cryo_Lab CTN SUS_Lab TCS_Lab OMC_Lab CRIME_Lab FEA ENG_Labs OptContFac Mariner WBEEShop
  PSL  Not logged in ELOG logo
Entry  Mon Jul 29 22:30:34 2013, tara, Notes, optic, coating optimization for AlGaAs multilayer1.JPGmultilayer2.JPGopt1_2013_07_29.pngnb_opt1_2013_07_29.pngT1200003_refcav.png
    Reply  Wed Jul 31 00:31:39 2013, tara, Notes, optic, coating optimization for AlGaAs 
       Reply  Fri Aug 9 17:58:01 2013, tara, Notes, optic, coating optimization for AlGaAs TOoptimized_2013_08_09.pngTOoptimized_2013_08_09.figTO_opt_200ppm_layer.pngTO_opt_200ppm_layer.fig2013_08_09_TOopt_200ppm.mat
          Reply  Tue Aug 27 16:11:26 2013, tara, Notes, optic, coating optimization for AlGaAs:error analysis 8x
             Reply  Wed Aug 28 21:21:38 2013, tara, Notes, optic, GWINC for TO calculation: recap 
             Reply  Sun Sep 1 18:38:37 2013, tara, Notes, optic, coating optimization for AlGaAs:error analysis 7x
                Reply  Mon Sep 2 18:31:46 2013, tara, Notes, optic, coating optimization for AlGaAs:error analysis 
                   Reply  Wed Sep 18 21:55:11 2013, tara, Notes, optic, coating optimization for AlGaAs:error analysis opt_coatings.mat
                      Reply  Thu Sep 19 20:38:17 2013, tara, Notes, optic, coating optimization for AlGaAs:error analysis power_vs_mirror_size.png
                Reply  Fri Sep 20 19:26:45 2013, tara, Notes, optic, coating optimization for AlGaAs:error analysis error_check_params.pngerror_check_params.figerror_thick_params_compare.pngerror_thick_params_compare.fig
                   Reply  Fri Sep 20 21:19:29 2013, Matt A., Notes, optic, coating optimization for AlGaAs:error analysis 
                   Reply  Sat Sep 21 23:49:29 2013, rana, Notes, optic, coating optimization for AlGaAs:error analysis 
                      Reply  Sun Sep 22 00:27:09 2013, some random goon, Notes, optic, coating optimization for AlGaAs:error analysis 
                         Reply  Mon Sep 23 18:07:22 2013, rana, Notes, optic, coating optimization for AlGaAs:error analysis 
                            Reply  Mon Sep 23 18:50:05 2013, tara, Notes, optic, coating optimization for AlGaAs:error analysis compare_indices.pngcompare_indices.figcompare_indices.png
                               Reply  Thu Sep 26 23:25:40 2013, tara, Notes, optic, coating optimization for AlGaAs:error analysis  8x
                                  Reply  Thu Oct 3 10:34:32 2013, tara, Notes, optic, coating optimization for AlGaAs:error analysis  
                                     Reply  Thu Oct 10 01:59:24 2013, tara, Notes, optic, coating optimization for AlGaAs:error analysis  
                                        Reply  Fri Oct 11 15:23:54 2013, tara, Notes, optic, coating optimization for AlGaAs:electric field in coating layer 6x
                                           Reply  Mon Oct 14 21:02:00 2013, tara, Notes, optic, coating optimization for AlGaAs:variation in x 
                                           Reply  Sun Oct 27 20:12:25 2013, tara, Notes, optic, photothermal noise in AlGaAs Int_cotings.pngInt_cotings.fig
                                              Reply  Wed Dec 18 21:05:28 2013, tara, Notes, optic, photothermal noise in AlGaAs: thickness resolution 8x
                                                 Reply  Sat May 17 22:01:28 2014, tara, Notes, optic, Coating TO opt for Adv LIGO: ETM 7x
                                                    Reply  Sun May 18 10:45:42 2014, tara, Notes, optic, Coating TO opt for Adv LIGO dOpt_ITM1.pngdOpt_ITM1.figAdvLIGO_AlGaAs.pngAdvLIGO_AlGaAs.fig
                                           Reply  Sat Jun 20 10:14:50 2015, Evan, Notes, optic, coating optimization for AlGaAs:electric field in coating layer Efieldtrans.pdf
Message ID: 1291     Entry time: Fri Aug 9 17:58:01 2013     In reply to: 1269     Reply to this: 1315
Author: tara 
Type: Notes 
Category: optic 
Subject: coating optimization for AlGaAs 

Better TO optimized coatings calculation is done. Now the Transmission, phase reflection, and TO noise are optimized.

From previous elog, these are explanation about the optimization codes.

Quote:

The codes for optimizing Thermo-optic noise in coatings are up on svn.

I adopt some codes that have been on svn for awhile and modified them for AlGaAs coatings. There are two main codes

.......

    2) optAlGaAs.m

        This file is the modification of optETM.m found in ../iscmodeling/coating/AlGaAs/optETM.m .It calculates the reflectivity and the TO coefficients from the given layer structure. The modifications are:

  • (Line41-45) Layer structure, the cap start with nH. The material for substrate is SiO2 with nsub = 1.45.
  • (Line60) Desired transmission, as a test, I chose 200 ppm.
  • (Line88) Calculation for TO coefficients (StoZ), I switched from getCoatThermoOptics.m to getCoatThermoOPticsAGS.m. Codes with AGS suffix in /GwincDev folder are fixed for AlGaAs coatings structure. This code calls many functions in /GwincDev folder.

.......    

 So optAlGaAs.m calculates a parameter y which is the cost function that is minimized in fmincon in doAlGaAs.m code.  Originally the cost function y includes the difference between the expected transmission and the transmission from the given layer, and the level of TO noise which are:

y = [(T - <T>) / <T>]^2   + sTO (f0).   The goal is to minimize y.   Where

  • T = transmission of the mirror with the optimized layers
  • <T> is the required Transmission
  • sTO(f0) is TO noise at f0
  • Each effect is weighted differently

This cost function does not care about the total phase of the reflected beam. T is the absolute value of the transmission, so the information about the phase is removed, and the optmized coatings calculated from this cost function won't have phase close to 180 degree. The previous result showed 180-1.2 degree.

So I added the phase of the reflection in the cost function, with appropriate weight, and ran the optimization.

==Phase calculation==

rCoat is the reflectivity of the coatings, by using atan(imag(rCoat)/real(rCoat)), we obtain the phase of the reflectivity. I tried to you atan2(y,x) to get the phase of 180, but it does not work well with the optimization. I'm not sure why. So I use atan function, and check the value of rCoat after the optimization to make sure that rCoat is close to -1 + 0i. The result is shown below.

TO_opt_200ppm_layer.png

above: the layer structure, optimized for 200ppm, y axis is in unit of lambda in the layer. The first layer is the 1/4 wave cap, the last layer is the layer just before the substrate.

TOoptimized_2013_08_09.png

above: noise budget for the optmized structure, the reflection phase is 180- 1e-6 degree.

 The layer structure is attached below in .mat format. Note: the structure does not include 1/4 cap on top.

== summary of the modifications of optAlGaAs.m==

  • (line 90 - 95) add calculation of the phase of the reflectivity
  • line 97 the cost function includes phase of the reflectivity that is close to 180 degree (r is close to -1 + 0i). The weigh functions  from TO noise/transmission/phase are chosen so that each factor are about the same, and the result looks reasonable ( coating thickness ~0.1 - 0.3 lamda, correct reflectivity, correct transmission).
Attachment 2: TOoptimized_2013_08_09.fig  122 kB  Uploaded Fri Aug 9 20:30:14 2013
Attachment 4: TO_opt_200ppm_layer.fig  14 kB  Uploaded Fri Aug 9 20:39:26 2013
Attachment 5: 2013_08_09_TOopt_200ppm.mat  625 Bytes  Uploaded Fri Aug 9 20:42:45 2013
ELOG V3.1.3-