40m QIL Cryo_Lab CTN SUS_Lab TCS_Lab OMC_Lab CRIME_Lab FEA ENG_Labs OptContFac Mariner WBEEShop
  40m Log  Not logged in ELOG logo
Entry  Tue Jul 27 18:42:57 2010, Gopal, Update, Optic Stacks, Bode Magnitude Plot and Concerns Bode_Mag_MC1_MC3.png
    Reply  Wed Jul 28 01:05:44 2010, rana, Update, SEI, Bode Magnitude Plot and Concerns 
       Reply  Wed Jul 28 12:16:03 2010, Gopal, Update, SEI, Bode Magnitude Plot and Concerns Bode_Disp_MC1_MC3_y.png
Message ID: 3306     Entry time: Wed Jul 28 12:16:03 2010     In reply to: 3304
Author: Gopal 
Type: Update 
Category: SEI 
Subject: Bode Magnitude Plot and Concerns 


1) Gravity has to be included because the inverted pendulum effect changes the resonant frequencies. The deflection from gravity is tiny but the change in the dynamics is not. The results are not accurate without it. The z-direction probably is unaffected by gravity, but the tilt modes really feel it.

2) You should try a better meshing. Right now COMSOL is calculating a lot of strain/stress in the steel plates. For our purposes, we can imagine that the steel is infinitely stiff. There are options in COMSOL to change the meshing density in the different materials - as we can see from your previous plots, all the action is in the rubber.

3) I don't think the mesh density directly limits the upper measurement frequency. When you redo the swept-sine using the matlab scripting, use a logarithmic frequency grid like we usually do for the Bode plots. The measurement axis should go from 0.1 - 30 Hz and have ~100 points.

In any case, the whole thing looks promising: we've got real solid models and we're on the merge of being able to duplicate numerically the Dugolini-Vass-Weinstein measurements.

I made some progress on a couple issues:

1) I figured out how to create log-transfer function plots directly in COMSOL, which eliminates the hassle of toggling between programs.

2) Instead of plotting maximum displacement, which could lead to inconsistencies, I've started using point displacement, standardizing to the center of the top surface.

3) I discovered that the displacement can be measured as a field vector, so the minor couplings between each translational direction (due to the asymmetry in the original designs) can be easily ignored. 


ELOG V3.1.3-