Here is the comparison before and after the fix.
Before the work, the UGF was ~40kHz. The phase margin was ~5deg. This caused huge bump of the frequency noise.
After the LO power increase, I had to reduce the MC loop gain (VCO Gain) from 18dB to 6dB. This resulted 4dB (x2.5) increase of the OLTF. This means that my fix increased the optical gain by 16dB (x6.3). The resulting UGF and phase mergin were measured to be 117kHz and 31deg, respectively.
Now I was curious to see if the PMC err shows reasonable improvement when the IMC is locked. Attachment 2 shows the latest comparison of the PMC err with and without the IMC locked. The PMC error has been taken up to 500kHz. The errors were divided by 17.5kHz LPF and 150kHz LPF to compensate the sensing response. The PMC cavity pole was ignored in this calculation. T990025 saids the PMC finesse is 4400 and the cavity pole is 174kHz. If this is true, this also needs to be applied.
Observations:
1. Now we can see improvement of the PMC error in the region between 10kHz to 70kHz.
2. The sharp peak at 8kHz is due to the marginally stable PMC servo. We should implement another notch there. T990025 suggests that the body resonance of the PMC spacer is somewhere around there. We might be able to damp it by placing a lossy material on it.
3. Similarly, the features at 12kHz and 28kHz is coming from the PMC. They are seen in the OLTF of the PMC loop.
4. The large peak at 36kHz does not change with the IMC state. This does mean that it is coming from the laser itself, or anything high-Q of the PMC. This signal is seen in the IMC error too.
5. 72kHz, 108kHz, 144kHz: Harmonics of 36kHz?
6. Broad feature from 40kHz to 200kHz. The IMC loop is adding the noise. This is the frequency range of the PC drive. Is something in the PC drive noisy???
7. The feature at 130kHz. Unknown. Seems not related to IMC. The laser noise or the PMC noise.
Remaining IMC issues:
Done (Nov 23, 2015) - 29.5MHz oscillator output degraded. Possibly unstable and noisy. Do we have any replacement? Can we take a Marconi back from one of the labs?
Done (Nov 23, 2015) - Too high LO?
- Large 36kHz peak in the IMC
- IMC loop shape optimization
- IMC locking issue. The lock streatch is not long.
- IMC PC drive issue. Could be related to the above issue.
Maybe not relevant - PC drive noise? |