We tried several times tonight to engage the Fool path with the PRFPMI. No success.
First, we locked the arms on ALS, in CARM/DARM mode, and measured the cancellation ability, to make sure that the filter shape and gain was set correctly. For the PRFPMI, it was okay using the same shape as the single arm case, but the gain was +20.0. There might be a bit more cancellation to be gained if we adjust the shape at the ~1dB level, but we're already able to get 20dB of cancellation, so we decided that would be enough to give things a try. To get this much cancellation, we set the phase tracker loops to both have 2kHz UGFs, almost exactly. We should implement a UGF servo, or the amplitude method version of that as Koji suggested ages ago, so that the phase tracker is always at the same place.
I don't think that REFL 11 is seeing as much CARM as I expect. We ended up switching over to linearized REFL55 for our attempts. When we're close to zero CARM offset, the arms are constantly flashing through resonance, and we get the loud buzzing. REFL11 doesn't seem to see any of this, even though we should be close enough to see some PDH action. REFL55 does change as we get closer to resonance, so I think it's seeing some real CARM stuff.
We tried engaging the Fool, but I don't think it did anything too useful. We need to make an estimate of what we expect our gain of the REFL loop to be - or at least the sign.
The PRMI is still not stable enough. It keeps falling out of lock when we get to high-ish arm powers. Not good. More brain power tomorrow on the modulation cancellation issue.
Perhaps if things are stable at moderate arm powers, we can use an excitation to line up the ALS vs. REFL error signals, and then watch the noises of them change as we move around in CARM offset. This should tell us when the linearized REFL signal is quiet enough that it's worth triggering and trying to transfer over.
The last lockloss tonight, there was something funny going on, that we can't explain. Even though both arms were locked on the CARM/DARM combined ALS signals, beatx doesn't see the giant oscillation that causes carm to lose lock until much later. Fool was trying to do something, but that should affect both als individal signals in the same way. Mystery.